Transcript of Hearing on TRO 5/30/95 Continued

23

MR. BRENNAN: Thank you, Your Honor. Bruce Brennan, Assistant Corporation Counsel, Your Honor.

THE COURT: Bruce?

MR. BRENNAN: Brennan, Your Honor.

THE COURT: All right, Mr. BRENNAN. thank you. I appreciate your being here.

MR. BRENNAN: I am sorry we just made it in the nick of time. There was -- your increased security here caused the Captain to stop down and leave his weapon with your guards downstairs. I do want to let you know that I do have with me the Captain, the Police captain Involved.

THE COURT: Right.

MR. BRENNAN: We did not anticipate taking testimony, but certainly if You Honor has any questions, I think as you know, all of our cursory readings of his complaint would lead to an indication that certainly the Captain ought to be dismissed, and I don’t know if there is any complaint against the district that really stands here. Certainly as far as the TRO --

THE COURT: Well, it is alleged, is it not, that he made an unlawful arrest, is that right

MR. BRENNAN: There was a violation of the First Amendment, that is what he said. And perhaps there was arbitrary and unequal enforcement of the regulations.

THE COURT: He doesn't say that. He doesn't say 24 unequal enforcement of regulations, does he? Where?

MR. BRENNAN: Perhaps I have mischaracterized the language, Your Honor.

THE COURT: Where Does it say that? Take your time.

MR. BRENNAN: My understanding is that he does object to the arrest, and Your Honor is correct in that. We think that the P.C.

THE COURT: Can you supply the court with any testimonial evidence by the Captain that he was acting lawfully and properly in accordance with the D.C.M.R.

MR. BRENNAN: Indeed, Your honor --

THE COURT: -- or the District of Columbia code?

MR. BRENNAN: Your Honor, 24 D.C.M.R. 100.1 provides that no person, or individual, or obstruction -obstruction to the streets of the District of Columbia is permitted. We do have

THE COURT: All right. Put the captain on the stand, and Madam clerk, administer the oath, and state for the record exactly what happened.

MR. BRENNAN: certainly, Your Honor.

THE COURT: Thank you.

M. J. RADZILOWSKI Government Witness, SWORN

DIRECT EXAMINATION

THE COURT: Give us your full name and occupation,


25

sir?

THE WITNESS: Yes, Your Honor. Michael Radailowski. I am a Captain assigned to the Metropolitan Police Department, Special operations Division.

THE COURT: And did there come a time when you had occasion to recently, during this month, see the plaintiff, Mr. William Thomas?

THE WITNESS: Yes, Your Honor.

THE COURT: On what occasion was that? Tell us the circumstances?

THE WITNESS: Well, YOUR Honor, I was on Pennsylvania Avenue with the Secret Service and some park representatives about movie making on Pennsylvania Avenue.

THE COURT: About what'

THE WITNESS: About movie making.

THE COURT: Movie making?

THE WITNESS: Movie making.

THE COURT: M-o-v-I-e.

THE WITNESS: Yes, sir,

THE COURT: All right. What day was that

THE WITNESS: I believe it was a Wednesday at about 2:00 o'clock.

THE COURT: Do you need a calendar? Let the record show that the Court has handed the witness a calendar, 1995, May. All right, Captain. What day was it that you saw the


26

plaintiff this month?

THE WITNESS: I thought that it was Wednesday, Your Honor.

THE COURT: What date was it?

THE WITNESS: I thought it was Wednesday, the twenty-fourth.

THE COURT: All right. Was that the day that you were arrested, Mr., Thomas

MR. THOMAS: No, it wasn't,

THE COURT: What day were you arrested on?

MR. THOMAS: May the 26th.

THE COURT: May the 26th. All right,, did you see the plaintiff on May the 24th, Captain

THE WITNESS: That is the day that I thought it was, Your Honor.

THE COURT: And he says it is on another date, the twenty-sixty do you say?

MR. THOMAS: Yes.

THE COURT: What time of day was it, sir?

THE WITNESS: It was approximately 2:00 o'clock in the afternoon, sir.

THE COURT: Do you agree with that, Mr. Thomas?

MR. THOMAS: That is close enough.

THE COURT: All right. What happened when -- tell us what happened


27

THE WITNESS: Well, Your Honor, I was standing on the sidewalk on the north side of Lafayette park when I saw Mr. Thomas

THE COURT: Wait a minute, the north side of Lafayette Park, That means -

THE WITNESS: The --

THE COURT: Listen.

THE WITNESS: Yes, Sir.

THE COURT: That means the side nearest the U. S. Chamber of Commerce.

THE WITNESS: yes, sir.

THE COURT: All right, good.

THE WITNESS: But that --

THE COURT: IS that inaccurate?

THE WITNESS: Yes sir. Thank you for correcting me. I was standing on the North side of Pennsylvania Avenue on the south Side of Lafayette Bark.

THE COURT: All right.

THE WITNESS: At which time, directly in front of the White House, coming from the South side of the park, I observed Mr., Thomas and another individual drag what I would describe as a sawed off lifeguard chair, which was very large and very big, into the middle of the street.

THE COURT: How much are you indicating, how wide and haw large it is


28

THE WITNESS: It looks like to me like three feet -- approximately three feet long and three feet wide, with a big back take had various messages written on it

THE COURT: How high was it

THE WITNESS: 1 -- approximate -- it was approximately three, three and a half feet or so.

THE COURT: High?

THE WITNESS: Yes, sir.

THE COURT: How wide?

THE WITNESS: Approximately three feet.

THE COURT: And what happened after that?

THE WITNESS: Well, after the meeting was over I went over and talked to MR. Thomas. I advised him that he couldn’t have

THE COURT: Wait a minute, excuse me. I apologize for interrupting you,

THE WITNESS: Yes, sir.

THE COURT: After the meeting was over, the meeting between whom?

THE WITNESS: The meeting that I was standing there discussing these movie details with the Secret Service and people from the United States Park Service.

THE COURT: All right.

THE WITNESS: which lasted approximately ten minutes.


29

THE COURT: All night.

THE WITNESS: As soon as the meeting was over, I walked to Mr. Thomas.

THE COURT: And where was he when you walked to him?

THE WITNESS: He was in the middle of Pennsylvania Avenue, directly in front of the White House.

THE COURT: All right. What happened then?

THE WITNESS: I engaged Mr. Thomas in a discussion, advised him that he could not have the structure in the middle of Pennsylvania Avenue, and at which time Mr. Thomas told me that he had talked to somebody from the Corporation counsel who told him that he could have it in the middle of Pennsylvania avenue, at which time I then explained it to him why he couldn’t have it on the street in front of Pennsylvania Avenue.

And I told him that he would have to take it back into the park where he could legally be, because that is where he was. And at that time Mr. Thomas refused to remove the structure from Pennsylvania Avenue, and I told him that if he did not move the structure from Pennsylvania Avenue, which was obstructing the avenue, I would have to have him arrested for failing to Obey a lawful order.

THE COURT: All right, Captain. You say -- was Mr. Thomas alone or Was he with somebody as these artifacts, ~~


30

whatever they were, were dragged out onto the street from the park? the street being Pennsylvania Avenue in front of the white House.

THE WITNESS: Yes, sir. At the time that he dragged it out, there was another individual who helped him.

THE COURT: Was it a male or female?

THE WITNESS: It was a male, sir.

THE COURT: Did you get that person’s name?

THE WITNESS: No, Your Honor

THE COURT: When YOU had your conversation with Mr., Thomas, was anybody else present?

THE WITNESS: Yes, Your Honor.

THE COURT: Who

THE WITNESS: Officer Rhonda Smith.

THE COURT: Spell it.

THE WITNESS: R-h-o-n-d-a, Smith, S-m-i-t-h.

THE COURT: Was she -- where was she standing when you had this conversation?

THE WITNESS: She was standing approximately two feet to my right,

THE COURT: Was she in a position to hear and understand everything that you said to Mr. Thomas and everything that, he said in response thereto?

THE WITNESS: I believe so, Your Honor.

THE COURT: All right. What did you say to him,


31

and what did he say to you, insofar as you can recall, the exact words?

THE WITNESS: The exact words were -- I told -explained to Mr. Thomas that even though the avenue was closed to regular vehicular traffic, it was still a roadway being used by the fire department, ambulance service, and all of the various police agencies, and we have motorcades on the avenue.

And besides that, he was occupying public space without a permit, and those were the things that he had --were violating. Mr. Thomas then wanted to engage in an argument, and I ceased the conversation, told him that I wasn't going to argue about it.

I tried to be nice about it, and explained to him what was going on, and why we were asking him to move, and when he refused the lawful order to move out of the roadway, that is the time that he was placed under arrest.

THE COURT: By whom?

THE WITNESS: By Officer Hebron.

THE COURT: Yes, What happened then

THE WITNESS: Then the wagon came on to Pennsylvania Avenue. We searched Mr. Thomas Took him to the precinct to process, and two of Mr. Thomas's friends came out of the park and dragged the structure back into Lafayette Park.


32

THE COURT: Were they male or female? Who were they?

THE WITNESS: I don't know who they were, Your Honor, but it was two males.

THE COURT: All right, Can you give us the Citation to the code, or the police regulations that you utilized in arresting Mr. Thomas?

THE WITNESS: I don't know the specific numbers, Your Honor, no.

THE COURT: And what did you say on your complaint, or arresting documents?

THE WITNESS: The arresting officer prepared the arrest -- the actual documents themselves. I did not see he was charged with failing to obey the lawful order under the traffic code, because he was in the street. And we did not charge him with occupying public space without a permit.

THE COURT: But you could have?

THE WITNESS: Yes, Your Honor.

THE COURT: And you still could?

THE WITNESS: I don’t know. I would have to seek legal counsel on that now that it is after the fact. But we did not. I tried very hard to talk to Mr. Thomas, explain to him what was going on, and why we were doing what we were doing, but it was to no avail.

THE COURT: Do you have any further questions?


33

BY MR, BRENNAN:

Q: Were there any other individuals, Captain, carrying signs in the street?
A: Yes.

THE COURT: What happened to them, if anything?

THE WITNESS: Nothing, Your Honor.

MR. BRENNAN: I have no further questions, Your Honor.

THE COURT: Do you mean that you just arrested Mr. Thomas and let all of the other people carry signs out there in front of the White House on the avenue?

THE WITNESS: Well, we can have -- there can be people in the street carrying signs. We don't have a problem with that, because they can get out of the street very quickly.

The problem was this large structure that Mr. Thomas had, which would require two people to pull out of the street, and he was actually occupying space as opposed to people demonstrating, walking around with their signs.

THE COURT: All right. Thank you.

MR. BRENNAN: No further questions, Your Honor.

THE COURT: Does the government have any questions that they want to ask the Captain?

MR. LAWRENCE: No questions, Your Honor.

THE COURT: Mr. Thomas?


34

MR. THOMAS: A few, Your Honor.