NUCLEAR PLANT IN RUSSIA LEAKS RADIOACTIVE GAS
By Margaret Shapiro
Washington Post Foreign Service
Wednesday, March 25, 1992
; Page A25
MOSCOW, MARCH 24
-- MOSCOW, MARCH 24 -- A nuclear power plant outside St. Petersburg was shut
down today after a leak of radiation, but Russian officials said the incident
poses no significant threat to the environment or nearby population.
Russian authorities said radioactive iodine leaked early this morning from
one of the four reactors at the Leningrad power plant, but that the only
contamination risk was on the plant's premises. Monitoring stations in
Austria, Sweden and Finland reported picking up no unusual amounts of
radiation in their areas.
Yuri Rogozhin, a spokesman for the Russian nuclear energy inspection
agency, said that while the incident was "serious," it was in no way
comparable to the 1986 disaster at the Chernobyl nuclear plant -- which killed
31 people, forced the evacuation of thousands more and spewed radioactivity
across Ukraine, Belarus and much of Europe -- or to the 1979 nuclear accident
at Three Mile Island in Pennsylvania.
Despite the official reassurances, today's incident at the plant near
Sosnovy Bor, 60 miles west of St. Petersburg -- formerly Leningrad -- on the
Gulf of Finland, rang alarm bells across Europe, where worries of
contamination from another Chernobyl run high.
A large number of aging nuclear power plants, many of questionable safety,
are still in operation in Eastern Europe, especially in the former Soviet
Union. Some nuclear experts have warned that a combination of design flaws,
age and poor maintenance make another major disaster inevitable and have urged
that many of these power plants be shut down.
"This accident is yet another example of how aging reactors are threatening
the world," said John Willis, a nuclear power specialist with the Greenpeace
environmental group.
Concerns are strongest over the reactors in the former Soviet Union,
because of the chaotic atmosphere in which many things seem to be crumbling. A
Russian newspaper recently reported cutbacks in operating personnel at some
nuclear plants.
There are 45 nuclear reactors at 15 nuclear power plants in the territory
of the former union; 16 of them, including those near St. Petersburg, are
based on the Chernobyl model, according to the International Atomic Energy
Agency in Vienna. These plants, which are built without any containment
structures that protect against leaks, produce about half of the nuclear power
in the former Soviet Union. Foreign experts have said that safety standards
have improved somewhat since the Chernobyl disaster but are still well below
international levels.
After hearing reports of Tuesday's leak, Germany's environment minister,
Klaus Toepfer, called for an immediate shutdown of all Chernobyl-type
reactors. "They must be switched off as soon as at all possible," he said at a
news conference in Bonn. He said the West should provide aid to help countries
in Eastern Europe and the former Soviet Union develop safer alternative
sources of energy.
While there have been no major nuclear accidents in the ex-Soviet republics
since Chernobyl, small incidents involving temporary shutdowns are reported
with some frequency. Chernobyl, for instance, was shut down briefly in October
because of a fire. And Leningrad was shut down momentarily last month after a
drop in power to the plant triggered its emergency system.
At the same time, economic pressures have made the continuing use of the
plants vital right now despite safety concerns. Chernobyl, which is north of
Kiev in Ukraine, for instance, is scheduled to be shut down for good in 1993,
but for now it continues to operate, with the reactor where the 1986 explosion
occurred encased in cement. Armenia, left without heat or electricity because
of an oil and coal blockade by neighboring Azerbaijan, may soon start up a
reactor that was shut down for safety reasons after the December 1988
earthquake.
Just two months ago, the Leningrad plant was criticized by Swedish
inspectors, who reported that its safety standards fell well below
international levels. They said the facility lacked proper equipment to
contain leaks in two of its four reactors. Russian nuclear energy officials
reported last month that two nuclear power plants, including Leningrad, were
no longer being operated at full capacity for safety reasons.
Greenpeace officials said the Leningrad plant had been under partial
rehabilitation recently. One reactor already had been refitted -- a process
that involves cleaning and strengthening the facility -- and the second
reactor's refitting was now underway. The third reactor, where the radiation
leaked early today, was scheduled to be shut down for rehabilitation soon,
they said.
According to Russia's Itar-Tass news service, the incident began at 2:37
a.m. when radioactive iodine leaked into the reactor's machine room, causing
radiation levels there to reach 10 times the normal level. The radioactivity
then escaped into the atmosphere through the ventilation system, passing
through cleansing filters first. Rogozhin, the spokesman for the regulatory
agency, said the power plant's emergency system was triggered immediately and
the facility then shut down.
According to Rogozhin, a team of investigators was sent from Moscow to
conduct a thorough inspection of the reactor, which will take about three days
to cool down completely. Rogozhin said officials are constantly monitoring
radioactivity levels at the power plant to see if any further leakage is
occurring.
He also said the incident was rated at level 3 on the IAEA's 7-point scale
of nuclear accidents, meaning there had been no off-site contamination.
The Russian Atomic Energy Ministry later downgraded the incident to a 2;
this, the IAEA said, "would indicate that no significant levels of radiation
exposure or contamination have occurred." Chernobyl, the worst nuclear
accident in history, was ranked at 7.
In St. Petersburg, meanwhile, city officials said they believed the
radiation had been contained and there was no reason for panic. The chairman
of the city council, Alexander Belyayev, said the third reactor would be
stopped for about four days for repairs and that the city would receive energy
supplies from elsewhere.
The Soviet Union has 15 nuclear plants with a total of 45 reactors. Both
Chernobyl and Leningrad, site of yesterday's accident, are older designs
considered unsafe due to a lack of containment. No reactors of this design are
operating commercially outside the former USSR.
........... YESTERDAY'S ACCIDENT ...........
The Leningrad nuclear plant is of the same type as Chernobyl, site of
world's worst nuclear accident.
Radioactive gases leak from Leningrad nuclear plant.
International Atomic Energy Agency accident scale
7. Major accident - Chernobyl (1986)
6. Serious accident
5. Accident with off-site risks
4. Accident mainly in installation
3. Serious incident
2. Incident - Leningrad nuclear plant
1. Anomaly
............... LOCATIONS AND TYPES OF REACTORS ..............
LENINGRAD
Yesterday:
A leak in the graphite tubing of reactor No. 3 emits a small amount of
radioactive gas into the atmosphere.
IGNALINA
July 10, 1991:
Leak contaminates three people and parts of the facility.
KURSK
June 26, 1989:
During repairs, radioactive water spills. Some leaks out of the building.
BALAKOVO
March 4, 1992:
Fire forces shutdown. No radiation is reported released.
CHERNOBYL
April 26, 1986:
Explosion, fire spread a cloud of radiation. Government says 32 people were
killed, but scientists and physicians claim the toll was at least 250 and
possibly as high as 10,000.
Oct. 11 and Nov. 1, 1991:
Fires at plant. No radiation release reported.
SOURCES: U.S. Council for Energy Awareness, Associated Press
Articles appear as they were originally printed in The Washington
Post and may not include subsequent corrections.
Return to Search Results