MORE THAN HANDOUTS FOR THE HOMELESS
Column: LETTERS TO THE EDITOR
Saturday, October 21, 1989
; Page A24
Former Rep. James Symington's letter {"Handouts for the Homeless," Oct. 17}
after the Housing Now! march suggesting we should respond to the homeless
problem by installing donation boxes at commuter locations is an indication of
how much remains to be done before the public understands the low-income
housing crisis. If this respected and compassionate former representative
believes that organizing the collection of handouts is a solution, then the
average citizen is probably equally ill-informed about the fundamental causes
of our housing problem.
First, the crisis is about maldistribution of income. The poor have gotten
poorer. The mean income of families with children declined 32 percent between
1973 and 1985. The poor have less real income to spend on housing or any basic
human need.
Second, the crisis is about the law of supply and demand and the fact that,
for the poor, housing prices have increased faster than income. Land and site
development are major factors. Yet, local and state governments continue to
drive up prices by creating unnecessary scarcity with overregulation,
higher-than-needed standards, regressive impact fees and property transfer
fees.
Third, the crisis is about housing subsidy policies. Effective housing
policy would direct subsidies to those least able to help themselves. Four
federal subsidy dollars go to the well-off via tax deductions for each housing
dollar that goes to the poor. This leaves many of my foreign friends wondering
about our mean-spiritedness, as we have cut housing subsidies for the poor
from $31 billion in 1981 to $7.5 billion today.
Fourth, the crisis is about the design and implementation of housing
programs. The best programs deliver housing assistance directly to those in
need, to their nonprofit or cooperative organizations or to responsible
direct-funded housing authorities. The best implementation taps the human
resources of the poor and involves them in the process.
Administrators should aim to make our democratic, free-market system work
for everyone, including the poor. It isn't necessary to deliver benefits to
the poor with tax write-offs to the rich or to hire poorly motivated
administrators who end their careers taking the Fifth before a congressional
committee.
The roots of our low-income housing crisis go deep. Solutions will require
more than handouts. What is needed is courageous, housing-literate political
officials willing to ask the electorate to make critical choices. Only then
can we move a growing number of Americans out of conditions more typically
associated with developing countries.
JAMES UPCHURCH President, Cooperative Housing Foundation Washington
I applaud Mr. Symington for his suggestion of strongboxes in strategic
locations.
The homeless are certainly an American problem, but strongboxes located at
international airport departure lounges would relieve some foreigners of their
small change and benefit those in need.
IZA G. WARNER Washington
Articles appear as they were originally printed in The Washington
Post and may not include subsequent corrections.
Return to Search Results